Find your Lawyer

Covid-19 update: Business as usual at Bolt Burdon Kemp

Bolt Burdon Kemp continues to remain very much open for business. We are passionate about achieving life-changing results for our clients, providing excellent client care and ensuring you receive the support you need.

We continue to progress our clients’ existing cases and support new clients with their cases.

All of our wonderful people are successfully working from home. We have re-opened our office so that those who need to work in the office are able to do so, in a socially distanced and safe manner. 

Our strategy of working in teams continues to ensure there is always someone for you to talk to. We are using telephone and video-conferencing very effectively. A number of multi-million pound cases have settled since the virus outbreak, using these facilities.

We are determined more than ever that the wheels of justice will keep on turning.

Contact us on 020 7288 4800 or info@boltburdonkemp.co.uk and one of our team will get in touch with you.

Read more from Managing Partner, Jonathan Wheeler

Round the clock support
Won't shy away from difficult cases
Committed to swiftly progressing claims

Level of Oversight For Life and Death Decisions

Key moral questions come straight into focus when you read about a case where judgement was handed down today regarding the withdrawal of life saving food and water from a person in a persistent vegetative state.

Despite the person dying before the judges reviewed the case it was decided that it was important that precedent was set for future such situations.

Vegetative State

If you are in a vegetative state it means that you are awake but you do not show signs of awareness.

This means that you might open your eyes, breathe and respond to some touch or noise but do not give meaningful responses or show signs of experiencing emotion.

A lot of brain injured people end up in a permanent vegetative state.  Almost all of them never come out of it.

Difficult Decision

The amount we know about the brain is severely limited… the amount we know about life itself… well…

To make matters even more difficult, the person in the permanent vegetative state has no ability to communicate what they would want to happen, so there needs to be a decision by other people on their behalf – judges, doctors, family members – about what should be done.  Whether life should be prolonged or food and hydration should be stopped.

Suffice to say it is an incredibly complicated area where opinions, facts, morals and beliefs all weigh in and judgements should be carefully scrutinised.

The reality of the decision handed down today is that if two doctors agree and “the family” is fine with it, then the court only needs to get involved if someone objects.  The requirement for the second doctor to be independent of the first is restricted to only if it is “reasonably practicable”.

My View

I am concerned by some of the reasoning employed in coming to this decision, as I would with any decision that cites lack of resources in the NHS or court system – which surely represent political issues not legal or moral ones?

The argument that doctors make life or death value judgements all the time is not a particularly reassuring one either.  This situation is very different from one where a decision is made to withdraw CPR.

My view is that if such a big decision is going to be made on behalf of someone who can’t speak for themselves then it should be open to public scrutiny.

I accept that running all such decisions through the Court of Protection, perhaps might not be the best way to make them, but that does not mean the lack of oversight set down in as acceptable in this judgement is enough to safeguard people who are in a persistent vegetative state.

Tom Lax is a senior solicitor in the Adult Brain Injury team at Bolt Burdon Kemp. If you or a loved one are concerned about the treatment you have received, contact Tom free of charge and in confidence on 020 7288 4840 or at TomLax@boltburdonkemp.co.uk. Alternatively, complete this form and one of the solicitors in the Medical Negligence team will contact you. Find out more about the Adult Brain Injury team.

Tom's Recent Posts

Brain Injury
Tom Lax Writes for The Herald

Tom Lax, associate solicitor in the Adult Brain Injury team at Bolt Burdon Kemp, writes for The Herald regarding Bolt Burdon Kemp sponsoring a day…

By Tom Lax
Brain Injury
One sided hearing loss and Brain Tumour Research

This week is International Brain Tumour Awareness Week. To mark that occasion Bolt Burdon Kemp are proud to sponsor a day of research at the…

By Tom Lax
Brain Injury
Tom Lax writes for Same Difference, 9 July 2020

By Tom Lax

Some of Our Accreditations

See more of our accreditations

We’re here to help you.

Want to talk to one of our experienced lawyers? We can call when it suits you for a no-obligation, strictly confidential chat.

Your browser is out of date. Please update your browser.

This site (and many others) provides a limited experience on unsupported browsers and not all functionality will work correctly or look its best.