When wealth buys silence and how injunctions and NDAs affect abuse survivors | Our Insights

Find lawyer icon
Find your Lawyer

Free call back
Contact us
Round the clock support
Won't shy away from difficult cases
Committed to swiftly progressing claims
020 7288 4800

When wealth buys silence and how injunctions and NDAs affect abuse survivors

Revelations surrounding Russell Brand and David Walliams have raised fresh questions about wealthy and powerful individuals using legal action to silence the media. But what impact does this have on survivors and their mental health?

From non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) and injunctions to strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs), these measures can also prevent survivors from discussing their experiences privately with friends, family and even therapists.

The difference between NDAs, injunctions and SLAPPs

These legal measures work in different ways, but can all be used to prevent allegations of wrongdoing from becoming public.

NDAs are contractual agreements which can prevent individuals from disclosing specific confidential information, including details of allegations or settlements, to the media and other third parties. However, they cannot lawfully prevent someone from reporting a crime to the police or making certain protected disclosures.

Injunctions are court orders which can prohibit the publication or disclosure of specified information. They may be sought to protect privacy, confidentiality or prevent harassment.

SLAPPs involve the use, or threat, of legal proceedings to intimidate individuals and discourage legitimate reporting, often through threatening correspondence warning that publication will result in costly litigation.

While these mechanisms can serve legitimate purposes, concerns arise when they are used to suppress allegations of wrongdoing or discourage survivors from speaking about their experiences. Importantly, even where certain disclosures are legally protected, the threat of legal action or uncertainty surrounding the restrictions imposed may be enough to prevent someone from speaking out or seeking support.

The recent cases involving Brand and Walliams illustrate these concerns.

In 2014, Brand and his then-partner Jemima Goldsmith obtained an injunction against massage therapist Sylvie Berki, who had made allegations of assault against him. The terms of the injunction reportedly imposed wide-ranging restrictions on her ability to discuss the incident, not only with journalists, but with friends and family. This has raised concerns about whether the injunction stopped her from seeking professional support.

A further example involves a woman originally identified as ‘Alice’, who described being in an abusive relationship with Brand when she was 16. She has since waived her right to anonymity, and we now know her to be Mia Latter. When she contacted his literary agency in 2020 seeking an apology, she reportedly received a letter from his lawyers accusing her of seeking money.

We, of course, now know that Brand has been sentenced to 10 years, 6 months in prison for rape and sexual assault.

David Walliams’ NDA and attempted injunction

Similar concerns have emerged in relation to David Walliams. Comedian Lucy Beaumont has spoken about a young woman, reportedly aged 19, who had been taken to Walliams’ dressing room and subsequently signed an NDA. The agreement reportedly prevented her from discussing her experience not only with the media, but also with friends, family and a therapist.

More recently, Walliams sought an injunction against ITV News and the Guardian to prevent publication of allegations concerning his conduct towards young women. His application partly relied on evidence that publication could have a serious impact on his mental health, including the risk of suicide, infringing on his right to life. The High Court ultimately refused the injunction, finding that the legal basis for restricting publication had not been established. Walliams has denied any wrongdoing.

A positive step for free speech

The refusal of the injunction was a welcome development for investigative journalism and freedom of expression. It demonstrates the importance of journalists being able to investigate allegations involving powerful individuals and provide a platform for those who may otherwise feel unable to speak out.

However, much of the discussion has focused on the impact on press freedom, with considerably less attention given to the impact these legal mechanisms can have on survivors themselves.

For someone who has experienced abuse, being prevented from speaking about what happened goes far beyond whether an allegation can be reported publicly.

Disclosure can be an important part of processing traumatic experiences, accessing professional support and beginning to recover. Being unable to discuss abuse with friends, family or a therapist can leave survivors isolated and compound the psychological harm they have already experienced.

This is particularly striking in light of the arguments advanced in the Walliams proceedings, where considerable attention was given to the potential impact of publication on his mental health, including the risk of suicide. While these concerns were rightly considered by the court, considerably less attention has been given to the potential psychological consequences for survivors who are prevented from speaking about their experiences.

If the courts consider the impact on the applicant’s mental health when deciding whether to allow publication, they should also consider the potential psychological harm caused by silencing those who have experienced abuse.

Our first-hand experience working with survivors

At Bolt Burdon Kemp, we regularly work with survivors of sexual abuse who have taken years, and sometimes decades, to disclose their experiences. We see first-hand the profound and lasting impact abuse can have on survivors’ mental health, including self-harm and suicidal ideation, and how important being able to speak about their experiences is to accessing support and beginning to recover.

Ultimately, the discussion surrounding NDAs, injunctions and SLAPPs must extend beyond the protection of reputations and freedom of the press. The interests and wellbeing of survivors must also be central to the conversation. Survivors should not have to choose between speaking about their experiences and facing the threat of legal action. Wealth and influence should never provide an individual with the means to silence those seeking to report wrongdoing.

If you are reading this as someone who has experienced any form of sexual abuse, whether recently or many years ago, support is available. Speaking to someone does not mean you have to make a report. If you would like to talk through what happened or explore what support might look like for you, our Abuse team is here to listen in complete confidence.

You can also contact Lara Rutler directly at lararutler@bbkllp.co.uk or Paul McGinn at paulmcginn@bbkllp.co.uk.

Some of Our Accreditations

See more of our accreditations

We’re here to help you.

Want to talk to one of our experienced lawyers? We can call when it suits you for a no-obligation, strictly confidential chat.

Your browser is out of date. Please update your browser.

This site (and many others) provides a limited experience on unsupported browsers and not all functionality will work correctly or look its best.