
Giving birth is a major life event, and the support women receive can play an important role throughout pregnancy, birth and the months that follow. But does the level of support women expect match what new mothers report experiencing as they recover?
To explore the gap between expectations and experiences of public maternity care in the UK, here at Bolt Burdon Kemp we’ve surveyed three groups of women: those who have given birth within the past two years, those who are currently pregnant, and those considering pregnancy within the next two years. We also analysed 241 publicly available UK birth-care threads on Reddit to understand how women frame and discuss their experiences online.
The gap between expectations and experiences begins around birth
Every woman’s experience of pregnancy, birth and recovery is different, and the support they need can vary throughout this journey. From feeling in control of decisions and having confidence in access to pain relief to receiving physical and emotional support after birth, the findings highlight areas where expectations and reported experiences differ.
More than one in five new mothers say physical recovery support fell short in the first 24 hours after birth

Most women expect or report feeling supported by the public healthcare system across physical recovery, mental wellbeing and emotional wellbeing in the first 24 hours after birth. However, recent mothers consistently report lower levels of support than pregnant women expect.
While 78% of new mothers felt supported with their physical recovery within 24 hours, just over one in five (21%) didn’t feel supported.
Percentage of women from each group who report or expect to feel supported after 24 hours in postpartum recovery:
| Area of recovery (24 hours) | New mothers (Reported support) | Pregnant women (Expected support) | Those planning (Expected support) |
| Physical Recovery | 78% | 86% | 82% |
| Mental Wellbeing | 73% | 80% | 76% |
| Emotional Wellbeing | 75% | 81% | 79% |
Looking at the differences between expectations and reality, physical recovery shows the clearest difference between women: 86% of pregnant women and 82% of women planning a pregnancy in the next two years expect to feel supported in the first 24 hours. A similar pattern appears for mental and emotional wellbeing.
Although the majority in both groups anticipate or report support, these differences point to a gap between expectations during pregnancy and experiences after birth.
Most new mothers reported feeling a strong amount of choice and control, however this wasn’t the experience for all women
The majority of women who have given birth in the past two years reported having a positive decision-making experience during birth, with four in five (81%) saying they had a great deal or a fair amount of choice over decisions, while 73% felt they had a great deal or a fair amount of control.
Pregnant women’s expectations were slightly higher, with 82% expecting to have a great deal or a fair amount of choice and 78% expecting to feel a great deal or a fair amount of control. This reveals a gap between expectations and lived experiences, particularly when it comes to control, where the proportion of pregnant women expecting to feel in control was 5 percentage points higher than the proportion of recent mothers who reported feeling this way.
| Measure | New mothers | Pregnant women | Difference |
| Choice | 81% | 82% | 1 pts |
| Control | 73% | 78% | 5 pts |
However, more than a quarter (26%) of women who have given birth within the last two years say they either felt as though they had little or no control over the decisions that were made during labour. Meanwhile, 18% said they felt as though they had little or no choice in decision-making during giving birth.
Percentage of women from each group who report or expect ‘not very much’ or ‘none at all’ choice and control over decisions when giving birth:
| Group | Choice: not very much or none at all | Control: not very much or none at all |
| New mothers | 18% | 26% |
| Pregnant women | 16% | 20% |
Olivia Boschat, Senior Associate and Women’s’ Health specialist says: “Feeling involved in decisions during labour is about more than being given information; it is about having the opportunity to ask questions, understand the options available and feel that your concerns are being taken seriously. When decisions need to be made quickly, taking the time to explain what is happening and why, wherever possible, can help women feel more informed and involved in their care. After birth, women should also feel able to discuss their experiences and access support if they have concerns about their recovery or the decisions made during labour.”
Most women are positive about pain relief during birth, but around one in six are not
While 79% of new mothers were satisfied with their access to pain relief during birth, 16% were not. To put this stat into perspective, around 600,000 women give birth every year through NHS hospital deliveries, which means around 100,000 didn’t feel satisfied with the pain relief they received.
Among pregnant women, 80% felt confident about the pain relief they would receive, while 18% did not; among women planning a pregnancy, 76% felt confident and 16% did not.
This means that around one in six women across the three groups therefore either lacked confidence in the pain relief they would receive or were dissatisfied with their experience.
Percentage of women from each group who were confident / expect to be satisfied with their access to pain relief when giving birth:
| Group | Satisfied/confident with pain relief | Not satisfied/confident |
| New mothers | 79% | 16% |
| Pregnant women | 80% | 18% |
| Women planning pregnancy | 76% | 16% |
To provide additional context, we also analysed 241 publicly available UK birth-care Reddit threads, examining the themes and sentiment across each. Discussions relating to consent during labour and birth choices were predominantly classified as mixed, accounting for 92% and 95% of relevant threads, respectively. Meanwhile, relief-related threads showed a more varied distribution: 70% were classified as mixed, 19% as negative and 11% as positive.
Olivia comments: “Effective pain management relies on open communication. Women need clear details about what relief is available, how quickly it can be arranged, and realistic information about potential delays, such as waiting for an anaesthetist. Clear communication throughout labour can help women understand their options and know what to expect if circumstances change.”
The postpartum support cliff as perceived support falls during post-birth recovery
While many women expect or report feeling supported in the immediate aftermath of birth, the picture changes as recovery progresses. Among recent mothers, the proportion who feel supported declines across physical recovery, mental wellbeing and emotional wellbeing over the following weeks and months.
The proportion of new mothers who feel supported by the public healthcare system with their physical recovery drops from 78% after 24 hours to 41% after three months
As we’ve seen, most women who have given birth within the last two years reported a strong level of support 24 hours after giving birth (78%). However, this falls over the following weeks, dropping to 64% at two to four weeks and 55% at five to eight weeks.
By two to three months after birth, fewer than half of new mothers (46%) feel supported with their physical recovery. Beyond three months, this falls to 41%, with around two in five (38%) saying they didn’t feel supported.

Mental and emotional wellbeing support follows a similar downward trend. Satisfaction with mental wellbeing support falls from 73% in the first 24 hours after birth to 42% at three months and beyond. Satisfaction with emotional wellbeing support drops from 75% to 42% over the same period. Overall, around two in five women said they did not feel adequately supported in their mental (37%) and emotional (38%) wellbeing three months after giving birth.
Expectations follow a similar downward slope amongst pregnant women, with expected support falling from 86% at 24 hours down to 45% at 3+ months, while women planning to give birth within the next two years expect a drop from 82% to 38%.
Commenting on why longer-term postpartum care can become less visible, Olivia goes on to say that:
“Postpartum care in the UK involves different types of support at different stages of recovery. In the early days after birth, care often focuses on immediate physical health, recovery and infant feeding. As women move from maternity services to community midwives, health visitors and GPs, the frequency and nature of contact can change.
At the six-week GP check, there may be a number of important aspects of recovery to discuss, but it can be difficult to cover everything in a short appointment. Issues such as pelvic floor dysfunction, complications from tears or other birth injuries may also develop or persist beyond the initial recovery period. This highlights the importance of women being able to access appropriate advice and support as their recovery progresses, particularly when their needs extend beyond the early weeks after birth.”
Pregnant women have higher expectations of long-term support compared to what new mums experience
When looking at expectations versus reality, women who haven’t yet given birth are consistently more optimistic about postpartum support than those who have experienced it firsthand.
At three months or more after birth, pregnant women expect higher levels of physical, mental and emotional support than new mothers report experiencing at the same stage. For physical support, 45% of pregnant women expect to feel supported three months or more after birth, compared with 41% of new mothers who report feeling supported. The gap is similar for mental support (46% vs 42%) and emotional support (48% vs 42%).
These figures compare different groups of women rather than tracking the same women over time, but they highlight a consistent difference between expectations during pregnancy and reported experiences after birth.
Percentage of pregnant women and new mothers who reported or expect to feel supported in each area 3+ months after giving birth:
| Area of recovery (3+ months postpartum) | Pregnant women (Expected support) | New mothers (Reported support) | Gap |
| Physical Recovery | 45% | 41% | 4 pts |
| Mental Wellbeing | 46% | 42% | 5 pts |
| Emotional Wellbeing | 48% | 42% | 6 pts |
Olivia adds: “The early weeks after birth involve frequent contact with maternity services, but women can face different experiences as they move further into recovery. Physical problems may not become apparent immediately, while emotional or mental health difficulties can also emerge or become more difficult to recognise over time. If women aren’t sure who to approach when concerns persist, it can become harder to access the support they need.”
A decline in reported support does not, by itself, indicate medical negligence. However, if a woman has suffered a physical or psychological injury during childbirth and believes it may have resulted from substandard care, she may wish to seek specialist advice. Bolt Burdon Kemp’s specialist birth injury solicitors can help mothers investigate whether their injury could have been avoided and whether there may be grounds for a claim.
The maternity gap doesn’t appear to end when a baby is born. Our findings suggest that while women generally feel more confident about the support available around labour and the immediate aftermath of birth, confidence and reported support fall as recovery continues.
For new mothers, that means the weeks and months after birth can represent a difference between expectations at the beginning of their maternity journey to their reported lived experiences. Ensuring women know where to turn when physical, mental or emotional difficulties continue beyond the early postpartum period is an important part of closing that gap.
Sources and methodology
We conducted a survey in September 2026 to 2,000 women aged 18+ in the UK with the following breakdowns:
- Women who have given birth
- Pregnant women
- Those planning to get pregnant at some point in the future
To keep our analysis in the campaign consistent, we have focused on the following groups of women:
- Women who have given birth within the last two years
- Pregnant women
- Those planning to get pregnant within the next two years
Reddit Sentiment Analysis:
To explore public conversations around birth care and maternity experiences in the UK, we analysed 241 Reddit thread topics using a sentiment analysis tool. This included examining the sentiment associated with each thread based on its original post title and Google search snippet. The Reddit analysis was used to support and contextualise the wider research findings, providing additional insight into the concerns and experiences being discussed online. It should not be interpreted as a standalone measure of public opinion or maternity care experiences.



