A toxic culture of power: the Smyth case

Channel Four has delved into John Smyth’s history of abuse, in its two-part documentary entitled See No Evil. Smyth has been called the most prolific serial abuser to be associated with the Church of England (CofE), and it is thought that during the 1970s and 1980s, Smyth subjected around 130 boys and young men to extreme physical and sexual abuse.

Smyth and his supporters believed they could target and recruit teenage boys and young men from what they viewed as the “best” schools and colleges – individuals they hoped would one day become leaders within the Church of England. In pursuit of this warped vision, Smyth subjected these young people to physical and sexual abuse, causing profound and lasting harm to them and those around them.

These abuses were not hidden. Smyth acted with relative openness, and he continued to attract apologists, supporters and enablers. His status created a barrier that shielded him from scrutiny and accountability. The Church, despite being aware of concerns about his behaviour, was at best ineffective in its response and at worst placed institutional reputation above the welfare of victims.

The Smyth case is not concluded. The Church needs to do right by the victims and accept responsibility for the harm suffered. Those who were in positions of responsibility but failed in their duties may still see action taken as a consequence.

The lesson is clear: when institutions place status and power above the people they are meant to serve, the results are toxic and deeply damaging.

We represent victims in the John Smyth case. If you are impacted by any of the issues related to this case, or other instances of abuse in the Church and you require legal advice, please do get in touch with our team for a confidential discussion.